Medpedia

The content on or accessible through Medpedia.com is for informational purposes only. Medpedia is not a substitute for professional advice or expert medical services from a qualified health professional. Read more

Medpedia Answers

(Other)

Medpedia Answers is a platform for asking and answering questions about health and medicine. Read more.

From the marriage vow point of view, can advanced Alzheimer's Disease represent Death and the marriage partner engage in extra-marital sex or have an acceptable excuse for divorce?

The question regarding the marital significance of Alzheimer's disease has been brought into the headlines recently by the television evangelist Pat Robertson's statements condoning divorce when a spouse has Alzheimer's Disease. Read the story in the Los Angeles Times: http://www.latimes.com/pat-robertson-alzheimers-comments-m,0,6539040.story

If a spouse is being cared for in an institution for end-stage Alzheimer's disease should the other marital partner be allowed to engage in extra-marital sex or file for divorce because of the spouse's condition and prognosis? ..Maurice.
asked Sep 16 at 09:52AM in Other
5 Answers
3 Following
↓ answer this question
Sort By Date Votes
  • 0
    Votes
    answered Sep 16 at 12:18PM
    Maurice,

    The terms of the marriage contract would have to be changed. The phrases of "till death do us part" and "in sickness and health" would need to be removed out of the contract. Almost dead is different than being dead. What about if your partner has sustained a severe brain injury such as a stroke or is in the last stage of terminal cancer?

    I see a potential conflict of interest. Can the spouse with Alzheimer's disease contest the divorce?
    Has the spouse with Alzheimer's disease given permission to the partner to the contract to have sex outside of that contractual marriage, before-hand?.

    Why did the partner wait so long into the progression of the disease to file for a divorce?

    Who is going to be the legal guardian of the spouse with Alzheimer's disease to represent his/her interest in any settlement/court case? The same partner who is having extra-marital sex or is seeking a divorce?

    In my humble opinion, If it is end stage, just wait; and provide the emotional support to your spouse, by your mere presence.
    • Will the partner be able to collect the life insurance on the diagonsis of advanced alzheimer's disease or does the partner have to wait until the actual death?
      Brendan C Francis MD commented Sep 16 at 12:29PM
  • 0
    Votes
    answered Sep 16 at 07:27PM
    The issue which was discussed extensively on Medpedia in the past was with regard to a husband having sex with his now mentally and physically incapacitated wife. The discussion can be found at the following link:

    http://www.medpedia.com/questions/1313-a-husband-having-sex-with-his-now-mentally-and-physically-incapacitated-wife-is-it-ethical-and-is-it-even-legal

    Do you think that a husband can legally have sex with his wife who is mentally incapacitated with Alzheimer's disease? Does this become a legal question as well as an ethical one? ..Maurice.
  • 0
    Votes
    answered Sep 17 at 05:35AM
    Is having sex with the wife for the greater good; providing emotional support for the spouses and keeping their marriage together? I would have to agree with Eric's answer:

    http://www.medpedia.com/questions/1313-a-husband-having-sex-with-his-now-mentally-and-physically-incapacitated-wife-is-it-ethical-and-is-it-even-legal

    I do not see it as unethical, once it is for the greater good. Legally, I would give the spouse the benefit of the doubt, seeing that the spouse would know his/her spouse much better emotionally, and would know what his/her spouse would agree to. As Eric had said, paraphrasing, you have to prove the case beyond the reasonable doubt.

    Can the spouse comfort his/her incapacitated partner, by singing to them, kissing,caressing, massaging, petting, holding hands, etc? How do you know that the incapacitated spouse is not able to 'feel" this care and is not emotionally benefitting by this closeness?

    "When there is reasonable doubt, do not convict."
  • 0
    Votes
    answered Sep 17 at 11:50AM
    I believe this is more of a question of personal ethics and morals than one for law or societal values. The simple fact is that the marriage "contract" is really more of a recitation of personal vows or religious convictions than a legal contract. I suspect the real answer is, "it depends."

    There would be no legal barrier to a person whose spouse has end stage Alzheimer's disease having extramarital sex with anyone they wanted. The real question, I suspect, is how that individual feels about the situation. If they are comfortable having extramarital sex with someone under those circumstances, then it is fine for them. If not, then they need to refrain from such activity until the end comes. Either way, it is not, nor should it be any my or society's business what two consenting adults do.

    As for the second half of the question, if a divorce occurs, there are a plethora of legal issues that would need to be dealt with, not the least of which are inheritance and guardianship. I suspect that if the answer to the first question is "yes" (i.e. a particular individual feels OK about extramarital sex under these circumstances), then they should simply wait for the death to occur before taking any action. If the answer is no, however, I would suggest that this is something that should be discussed before anything like this situation occurs (like an advanced directive or a power of attorney), so that provisions for inheritance and guardianship are made before a decision is required.
  • 0
    Votes
    answered Sep 17 at 02:52PM
    The other issue that comes up in the context of my Questions is how should physicians and the nursing staff in an institution housing the demented spouse respond when the patient, perhaps no longer remembering he or she had a marital partner, engages in sexual activity with others in the institution? There is much to learn about intimacy and sexuality of the Alzheimer's disease patient and a brief discussion of the topic can be found at the Alzheimer Society's website:
    http://www.alzheimer.ca/english/care/ethics-intimacy.htm
    With regard to my question just posed, the site says "As the disease progresses, people may no longer recognize or remember their partners, and may seek companionship and physical intimacy with a new partner in a long-term care facility. Due to the sensitivity of this issue, family members and staff may try to prevent people from fulfilling their needs outside of previously existing relationships." There is no advice on this matter other than "If the person with Alzheimer's disease chooses a new partner, it is important to ensure that those involved agree to the relationship, whatever form it takes." and "drawing attention away from a new relationship that might upset a partner". Any suggestions from a Medpedia reader if you were the physician or nurse in such a prolonged care institution and it was discovered that the Alzheimer patient was having sex with another patient? Would you keep the two separated? Would you inform the spouse? Or would you do nothing and consider the activity as "therapeutic" to both institutionalized parties? ..Maurice.
The content on or accessible through Medpedia.com is for informational purposes only. Medpedia is not a substitute for professional advice or expert medical services from a qualified health professional. Read more
Editor Directory - browse by last initial
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
Professional Directory - browse by last initial
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
Cancel